Cable vs. Satellite vs. Internet TV

In recent months, like many of you out there, I have been evaluating many things in the household as to what is needed and what isn't. Of course, slashing the cost of food/shelter where near the top of the list but couldn't be touched without some form of backslash in the family.

So the first thing that was on the chopping block was the Cable TV (and the phone lines are next) at $70 a month.  So after dropping the Cable TV, having it for 10+ years, and now receiving only the free over the air signals on the TVs did we realize why we had Cable TV to begin with. So instead of going back to Cable TV no more than 36 hours after dropping it, the search for a solution to better show access was underway.

Cable TV was no longer an option with its ever growing cost, so the next reasonable choose was Satellite. The fact of having issues with weather and the need to mount a dish on my house was enough to make me skip it as an option. While the cost of Satellite is about half the price of Cable TV, the thought of switching and paying someone else again kind of defeated the purpose of dropping Cable TV in the first place.

So the quest continued on. With Cable and Satellite not on the radar, there were only a few places to turn and they were physical media and downloading/streaming. Buying physical media awhile it is great to catch up on shows you might have missed; it tends to fill your house with plastic cases and boxes. An alternative to physical media is a much more none traditional way of watching shows on your TV and that is via electronic download/streaming. 

In the end, I went with what would be the most cost effective solution for my household based on the devices I already had in it. I am an avid gamer so I own Xbox 360 and a Nintendo Wii, both of which offer features that are not thought of as features of a gaming system. The Nintendo Wii offers Internet access via the Internet Channel. The Internet Channel allows you to browse to and watch videos from sites like You Tube, as long as they are using the Flash 7 file format. The Xbox 360 on the other hand allows you to access videos, music and pictures from a Windows PC or a USB device such as a hard drive.

After some experimenting off and on, I ended up using the Xbox 360 as a media extender due to its built in Netflix connection and support for Windows Media Center. So we signed up for Netflix which offers a Watch Now option to watch TV shows as well as movies. With their monthly plan of $8.99 you get unlimited streaming and can have unlimited DVDs, but only one DVD at a time. However, Netflix doesn't offer up everything in the terms of streaming that one might want, but it is a good start though.

Now with Netflix and a partial solution, the next step was to provide some additional choices because that is what it is all about anyways with Cable or Satellite. The next step was to be able to stream more videos on demand than what Netflix offered, and typically Netflix offers streaming of videos that are in physical format which leaves out new episodes with the exception of Heroes which you can watch the latest season and episodes for free via streaming from Netflix. To fill the void of new episodes and current shows, I could visit sites like ABC.com or NBC.com but that does not make for an easy solution for the rest of the family.

So in addition to Netflix, I installed PlayOn on my computer which allows me to stream videos from CBS, Hulu.com and even YouTube. While this is not true Internet TV, it does allow me to access recent episodes of such shows as 24, Chuck and Burn Notice to name just a few as well as classics or off the air shows such as Alf, Lost in Space and Reba. PlayOn is not the only solution out there, as the one that looks the most promising is a solution that is known as Boxee.

Boxee is in public alpha testing right now, and runs on Mac, Apple TV and Linux currently with a Windows solution in closed/private beta. Boxee allows you to stream from even more sources than PlayOn does and from a single interface. With PlayOn and Boxee out there, it will only be a matter of time until watching TV changes again like it did when Cable was first introduced.

Now this might not be for everyone out there, but it is a great way to get you closer to what you might watch now on Cable TV at a reduced cost. So the cost savings for me looks like:

$70 x 12 = 840 (is what I was paying the Cable company)
$9 x 12 = 108 (what I will be paying Netflix)
$30 (one time fee to PlayOn for their media server software)

$840 - 108 - 30 = $702 (First year savings) and $732 each year then forward, based on the rising cost of Cable TV the savings will most likely increase over time.

If you do not have an Xbox, but have high speed internet you can look into purchasing an Apple TV for $230 and making the necessary changes to run Boxee on it. So even after that you could be looking at about a savings of $500 a year with getting rid of Cable TV. I have not done this, but have thought of doing it on a few occasions simply for the sake of giving it a try.

Before going down this road, you will want to make sure your Internet service provider does not have bandwidth limits on the plan you use and there are additional costs that I did not list. Such as $199 for an Xbox 360 which I already owned and a PC that met the minimum requirements for PlayOn which was 1.5Ghz with 5GB of free space and 512MB of Ram. I hope this can open your eyes up to a whole new world of watching TV episodes and movies.

Sincerely,
  Lee

Comments

[RG]

I have been without cable for five months now...In the family room, we a computer hooked up to the our LCD tv and with netflix, hulu, amazon and itunes we can watch just about anything we want for a fraction of what we were paying for cable. Every once and a while we use the HD OTA signal for a show (which actually has better picture quality that our HD cable did) and I am planning on buying a eyeTV to handle some basic dvr functions. We use a bluetooth mouse and an onscreen keyboard as a remote control. we watch what we want when we want, and can check the email in between shows.

I also have an apple tv in the basement running boxee, but its value is limited. I would rec people skip the ATV and buy a mac mini instead. refurb mac mini - $499, bluetooth mouse - $69, netflix $108...$676

Another option is a roku...netflix and amazon capability already, and hulu is on the way...all from a tiny $99 box.

Sorry about the long post, just happy to hear more people are making the change to ITV. As more people do, the content will improve

[Lee Ambrosius]

As you mentioned there is a number of ways to go with ITV. I spent a little while doing some research before making the jump from Cable TV to ITV and am very happy with my switch so far. I have not done much research in the area of DVR yet, but will most likely use Windows Media Center at this point since that is what I have available to me.

Glad to hear about your experience though, and I too hope that people will begin to make the transition. However, it will most likely not happen until something like Apple TV or Boxee make it easy for the mainstream to do it. A box with combined ITV plus digital convertor would be ideal in a number of ways though at this point.

[Neurotic Nomad]

Six months ago I decided to cut the cable and depend on the internet for 100% of my television programming. With zero research and zero preparation, my wife and I jumped in feet first.

What a bumpy ride! We've saved $300 and learned a lot.

I just published part 2 of my 3 part Guide to Ditching Cable @ http://replacetelevision.wordpress.com/what-im-watching-and-how-im-watching-it/

I stream a LOT of material. I had the Roku Netflix box for a few months and loved it. I sold it to buy an AppleTV to run Boxee on, but then found out that Boxee for AppleTV doesn't support Netflix.

Now I'm getting a Mac mini if/when Apple bumps the specs and living without Netflix streaming. Until then, Hulu will do just nicely.

Of course... there's also downloads. Have you discovered T.E.D. ?

[Ami Roberts]

Hi,

I greatly enjoyed looking through your blog at "http://hyperpics.blogs.com/beyond_the_ui/2009/01/cable-tv-vs-satellite-vs-internet-tv.html" and found an informative one for my theme related topics.I have also some dish tv,satellite tv,music related sites and blogs. So,I think it would be beneficial for both of us if we will join in a community and become link partners to each other which will help your blog/site in getting more Google values.If you are interested then please contact me at-
[email protected]

Thanks
Ami

[David Wilsen]

Hi ,
Your work on the blog is fantastic. I’m influenced in a positive way.

Specifically, I got some nice information in this page http://hyperpics.blogs.com/beyond_the_ui/2009/01/cable-tv-vs-satellite-vs-internet-tv.html

If you are interested, I would like to exchange links by placing a content link in your website. Don’t you think it would be nice for both our sites?

I’m waiting for your response.
Regards,
David
Email: [email protected]

[Wes Thierry]

I have been doing this for about 5 months in San Francisco. We get all networks over the air in HD for free. Run Playon on a computer server which we connect to our PS3 for Hulu, Netflix, and some of the other playon plugins like food network, Discovery, and CBS and NBC, its not as conveinient as cable, but for the savings its great. I also recommend one of those programmable Logitech remotes to put your system in the right mode for others in the house who may not be as tech savy!

[VJJ]

You don't need Wii, Xbox, Playon, or Boxee to stream the videos from the major networks, cable channels, youtube, & internet TV channels. They just link to the source of the video... something you can already do on any PC or Mac anyway.

Even a lot of which is on Hulu is just linked to an originators source, & not actually served by Hulu. Just bookmark the stream section of your favorite channels & sources in a folder just for TV.

Surf the links the same as you'd surf TV channels. Try the torrents & P2P like Frostwire too. Not everything on the file share networks is illegal. Some of it's free to download, & put there by the originator & copyright owner.

My satellite only cuts out 1-2 times a year for less than a minute during only the most extreme storms... much less than my cable cut out per year. Sometimes channels would be missing or have a blocky distorted picture for days with cable too.

Be late paying your cable bill & they will cut you off. Then charge outrageous re-connect fees to turn it back on. If you're late paying satellite, they let you slide a long time before they even notify you that they may disconnect you in a few weeks.

When they do disconnect you, within a minute of paying your bill, the service is automatically restored at no additional charge.

The dish sometimes can be placed on the roof in back, the garage, or on a post where nobody will notice it.

Many years ago some people would refuse to have a phone or electricity because they didn't want those ugly wires running into their home, or on the inside. We can live in mud huts & caves, or keep up with the times.